Same tile, two prices. The gap is in the lines you can't see.

One Foshan supplier quotes $5/m², another $8 for what both call "600×600 porcelain". Sometimes the cheap one is better. Sometimes the expensive one is still underpriced. The unit price alone cannot tell you which — this page lists where the difference actually lives, and the one table that makes three quotes comparable.

Written by the Qianhe Sourcing team, Guangzhou · 17 November 2026 · 中文版

Short answer: the gap between two tile quotes is almost never profit margin — it is six cost lines that the one-line quotation does not show: body and absorption group, thickness and format, glaze and surface process, grade and shade control, packaging, and trade terms. Align those six lines first, and the quotes either converge or the difference explains itself. A quote that cannot fill in the lines is itself information.

First: put the prices on the same term

Before comparing anything, check what the price is actually quoted on. An EXW price and a CIF price differ by inland haulage, export clearance, ocean freight and insurance — none of which is a quality difference. This is the most common false comparison we see, and it is worth repeating the rule: never compare unit prices across different Incoterms. Convert everything to the same term first (for most buyers comparing factories in the same cluster, FOB at the same port is the cleanest basis).

The six lines behind the gap

Cost lineWhat variesHow it shows up in the price
Body & absorption groupGroup BIa (≤0.5%) porcelain versus a porous BIII body; body slip preparation and pressing pressureThe single biggest line. A Group BIa body costs more to make than a BIII wall-tile body — same nominal size, different product
Thickness & format9 mm vs 10 mm; large formats need bigger presses and tighter firing control10 mm carries more material and a higher breakage-avoidance margin; large formats price differently from standard modules
Glaze & surface processPolished, soft-polished, matte, moulded texture, dry-granule surfaces; ink and glaze qualitySurface process is where "looks similar in photos" tiles diverge — texture depth and wear behaviour differ long before the price does
Grade & shade controlGrade AAA/AA/first-choice policies; shade-lot discipline; whether out-of-grade goods are re-labelled or mixedA factory that keeps shade lots separate and grades honestly prices in that discipline. One that doesn't is selling you a claim instead
PackagingCarton weight, palletised vs loose-packed, corner protection, container dunnagePalletising adds real cost and removes real breakage risk. Loose-packed quotes look cheaper and ship you the difference
Quantity & schedulingMOQ, whether your order fills a kiln run or rides along, colour mix per cartonAn order that fits production runs cheaper. A rushed order squeezed between two runs prices accordingly

Lines are listed as they appear in Foshan-area tile quotations; this is a method reference, not a price benchmark. Specific figures belong to specific SKUs — see the stone-look porcelain series table for how we record them.

The one-page RFQ table

Send this to three suppliers and require every line filled. It converts three chatty quotations into one comparable table — and suppliers who resist filling it have answered your question.

#Line to fillWhy it matters
1Format × thickness (mm)Fixes the body cost; "same size" must be written, not assumed
2Water-absorption group — measured, per ISO 10545-3, not declaredDecides the product category; a declared "porcelain" that measures BIIa is a different product
3Surface process and wear class claimedPhotographs cannot compare surfaces; the process name and class can
4Grade policy + shade-lot rule in writingThe clause behind almost every "the new batch doesn't match" complaint
5Packaging: carton weight, palletised / loose, pieces per cartonPredicts breakage before it happens
6Price term and port (EXW / FOB / CIF)Makes the unit prices comparable at all
7MOQ and production window from order to ex-worksReveals whether the price assumes a full line or a squeeze-in
8Who pays sampling and pre-shipment inspectionSmall money; reveals how the factory expects disputes to go
9Test reports held, naming the standard (ISO 13006 / 10545 series)Connects the quote to compliance — see what a Saudi-bound factory must hold

What a cheap quote leaves out

The omitted lines are where the "saving" gets returned, with interest:

  • Breakage at the far end. Loose packing and thin cartons move cost out of the factory and into your container. The claim conversation happens after the money is paid.
  • Top-ups that no longer match. Without a written shade-lot rule, the second order's "same model" is a lottery — and nobody re-buys a whole floor because one batch drifted.
  • Acceptance disputes with no standard. If grade and tolerance were never written, every rejected carton is an opinion. The side with the deposit paid loses.
  • Compliance discovered late. A price that assumed no test reports will not survive a market that requires them — the SQM licence cannot be bought at shipment time.

Is the expensive quote automatically safer?

No — a premium price with the same blank specification line is the same risk at a higher price. What makes a quote safe is not the number; it is whether the number is attached to testable lines: an absorption group measured to ISO 10545-3, breaking strength to 10545-4, a shade tolerance expressed as a sealed sample or a numeric delta. When the specification is testable, the expensive quote has to justify itself line by line — and often, against a well-written RFQ, the mid-price supplier is the one who fills every line without flinching.

Questions buyers ask us

Why do two suppliers quote $5 and $8 for "the same" tile?

+

Because "the same" is doing all the work in that sentence. Absorption group, thickness, surface process, grade discipline, packaging and terms — any two of these can explain the whole gap. Fill the nine-line table and the difference either converges or explains itself.

Is the cheaper quote worse quality?

+

Not necessarily — it can be a leaner producer, a thinner body, a lower group, or a different trade term. What it never is, on its own, is information. Specification first, then price.

How do I compare quotes from different factories?

+

One RFQ table, every line mandatory: format and thickness, measured absorption group, surface process, grade and shade rule, packaging, price term and port, MOQ and window, sampling and inspection responsibility, and the reports they hold. Quotes that can't fill it have answered.

What does a cheap quote usually omit?

+

Palletising, spare tiles and shade-batch reservation, the acceptance standard, third-party inspection, and who bears port-of-discharge breakage. Each one comes back as a claim, a delay, or a mismatched top-up.

Should I just pick the most expensive quote?

+

A premium price with the same blank specification is the same risk at a higher price. Make the specification testable first — then every quote has to justify itself line by line.